John Losey speaking to an audience, mid-explanation

Ideas

Better judgment starts with the quality of our thinking.

Quality Thinking is IntoWisdom’s strategy for improving the quality of thinking and judgment, for individuals and organizations: noticing when a decision deserves deliberate thought, and then thinking it through well.

What IntoWisdom means by Quality Thinking

Quality Thinking starts with a simple question: can you explain and justify how you made the decision you did?

Most of the time, quick and intuitive thinking serves us well. The trouble comes when a situation looks simple but isn’t, or when the pressure to decide pushes us to choose before we’ve understood the problem. Quality Thinking is about catching those moments and slowing down on purpose.

It also gives individuals and organizations a common language and process for talking about how they think and make decisions. And it treats thinking as more than analysis: good judgment draws on critical thinking, which evaluates ideas and evidence; collaborative thinking, which brings in other people and perspectives; and creative thinking, which generates new possibilities.

Why this perspective matters

The quality of an organization’s decisions can’t be better than the quality of the thinking behind them.

Not every decision needs deep thought

Quality Thinking begins by asking whether a decision requires focus. Is the situation complex? Does it have important or lasting implications? Do I have strong personal views that might cloud my perspective? If not, act. If so, slow down.

Fast thinking is useful, but not always right

Psychologist Daniel Kahneman described two kinds of thinking: fast, intuitive “System 1” and slow, deliberate “System 2”. Fast thinking handles most of daily life. But some problems only seem easy, and Quality Thinking means recognizing them and deliberately engaging the slower kind.

Discomfort pushes people to decide too soon

When a decision is uncomfortable, the quickest way to relieve the feeling is to decide, about anything. Asking “When does this decision actually have to be made?” often reveals time for better thinking, and pondering time is real work.

Thinking happens in context

Our emotions, our mental models and our relationships all shape how we think, usually without our noticing. Self-awareness is part of thinking well, and so is seeing a decision in the wider system around it.

Judgment can be developed

Better judgment isn’t a fixed trait. It grows through self-awareness, critical evaluation of options and intentional action, practiced on real decisions.

The Quality Thinking Process

IntoWisdom’s Quality Thinking Process is a simple four-step cycle: Focus, Think, Act, Reflect. Each step comes with questions.

  1. Focus Is the issue clear? Drill down to the real issue, check assumptions and ask: how else might I see this, and what are my blind spots?
  2. Think What’s really happening? Who else might need to be involved? What are all my options, and what might happen as a result?
  3. Act What’s my plan? How will I get resources and communicate it? How will I know if it was a success? Then do it.
  4. Reflect Did my plan work as intended? What worked, what didn’t, and what did I learn that I can use next time?

It begins with a judgment prompt and one question: does this require focus? If not, act. If it does, the cycle begins.

A different way to look at decisions

IntoWisdom’s Intentional Questions help people start, clarify, check assumptions, explore data and decide. Here are a few of them.

  • Instead of only asking, “What’s the answer?” also ask, “How else might this issue be described?”
  • Instead of only asking, “Who agrees with me?” also ask, “Who do I know who might ask me hard questions about this issue?”
  • Instead of only asking, “What does the data say?” also ask, “How else might this data be interpreted?”
  • Instead of only asking, “Does this decision solve the problem?” also ask, “What other issues or problems might this decision create?”
  • Instead of only asking, “How soon can we act?” also ask, “What would happen if we waited to implement this decision?”

None of these questions makes decisions slower for the sake of it. They make room for the thinking a decision deserves.

Traps that undermine good judgment

Our minds rely on rules of thumb that are usually efficient but can lead to predictable errors. Decision researchers have described many of them; Quality Thinking asks people to recognize the ones that affect their own decisions.

Misleading rules of thumb

We judge what’s likely by what’s recent, vivid or frequent. We give too much weight to a first estimate or the first framing of a problem, and adjust from it too little. And we tend to be more confident than the evidence allows. Psychologists Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman described the first two of these in their research on how people judge under uncertainty.

The confirmation trap

Looking for information that supports what you already think, and ignoring what doesn’t.

Explaining people instead of situations

Assuming someone is late because they are careless, when traffic may be the better explanation. This tendency, known as the fundamental attribution error, overlooks the social and environmental factors that so often shape behavior in organizations. Its cousin, the self-serving bias, credits our successes to ourselves and our failures to circumstances.

Holding on to the past

Making choices that justify past decisions, even when they no longer make sense, and favoring whatever keeps things as they are. Decision researchers John Hammond, Ralph Keeney and Howard Raiffa named these the sunk-cost and status-quo traps.

Practical ways to compensate

Question the starting points. Invite someone to argue the strongest case against your preferred option. Check the quality of your sources and separate what the data actually shows from what it only suggests. And try a premortem, a technique developed by psychologist Gary Klein: imagine the plan has failed a year from now, and write the story of why.

What this looks like in practice

Here is how Quality Thinking shows up in IntoWisdom’s work. These are illustrations of the approach, not accounts of particular clients.

In workshops

The Quality Thinking workshop helps leaders, managers and professionals practice the Quality Thinking Process on real decisions.

In organizations

A shared process and common language help people throughout an organization make, and explain, sound decisions, not only the people at the top.

In advising and coaching

A thinking partner helps a leader focus on the real issue and take pondering time before an important decision.

In group decisions

Facilitated conversations can build in devil’s advocates, premortems and room for quieter voices, so a group’s thinking is better than any one person’s.

Where this idea connects to IntoWisdom’s work

Quality Thinking runs through these ideas and services.

Idea

Leadership

Judgment is at the heart of how IntoWisdom thinks about leadership.

From the IntoWisdom library

Articles, tools, events and resources connected to Quality Thinking.

Explore all Resources

What decision deserves more thought?

If you’re facing an important decision, or want to build better thinking habits in your team, we’d be glad to think it through with you.