Leadership

Paint Your Target First: Why Success Needs a Clear Frame

A boy in the countryside shows off a barn wall covered in arrows. Every shaft sits dead center in its own bullseye. “How’d you get so accurate?” a visitor asks. Easy, he shot first, then painted the targets afterward.

There’s an old story.

A boy in the countryside shows off a barn wall covered in arrows. Every shaft sits dead center in its own bullseye. “How’d you get so accurate?” a visitor asks. Easy, he shot first, then painted the targets afterward.

That’s what many teams do. They scramble, act, and only later declare whatever happened to be a success. It looks impressive. It’s an illusion. Real progress comes when you paint the target first, and let that target guide every shot.

While the archer story captures the illusion of success, it also reflects a deeper habit in business — one that favors action over clarity.

The Urge for a Shortcut

If you’ve spent time consulting, coaching, or leading, you’ve heard the plea: “Just tell me what to do.” It’s often impatient, sometimes desperate. The checklist feels safer than the pause. But too many leaders burn through energy chasing quick fixes without ever asking what “better” really means.

I once worked with a leadership team determined to “build trust.” Their first request? “Can you give us a script?” Weeks later, they were no closer to trust, because no one had named what trust would actually look like when built.

This isn’t only a business problem, a team problem, or a leadership problem. It’s a human problem. We are conditioned to act fast, rewarded for speed, and trained to fix what’s broken. But when all we see are problems, our thinking tends to recreate the conditions that created the problems.

Getting stuck in cycles of urgent action isn’t accidental; it’s conditioned into how we think and respond. To understand why pausing to frame success is so powerful, we need to look at what happens inside the mind.

The Brain Science of Framing Success

Modern neuroscience shows why painting the target first matters. When you picture a clear and meaningful “ideal state,” your brain doesn’t just clarify strategy, it rewires itself. The prefrontal cortex (the location for judgment and decision-making) and reward circuits light up, building new neural pathways that make it easier to spot opportunities, choose wisely, and persist when challenges hit.

Every vivid picture of success releases dopamine when you take even a small step toward it. This fuels motivation and resilience. By contrast, focusing only on fixing problems activates stress circuits that narrow perspective and push us back into reactivity.

We cannot solve our problems with the same level of thinking that created them.
 — Albert Einstein

Why Lists Keep Us Average

Most growth plans start with lists: training modules, to-dos, step-by-step procedures. That structure is useful. It gets people functional. But a checklist alone caps you at “average.” You can’t tick your way to transformation.

Checklists may help us function, but their limits become clear when we try to aim higher. Breaking through to lasting change demands a different approach.

The Transformational Bridge

Lasting change begins not with what you do, but with who you want to become or what you aim to achieve. When you define your “ideal state” first, then compare it honestly to your current state, you create productive tension. Your brain, restless in the gap, begins bridging it, designing strategies, spotting resources, and trying new behaviors that align with the vision.

Neuroscience confirms this: intentional goal-setting and visualizing success sharpen focus, filter out distractions, and sustain motivation. The checklist becomes a tool, not the finish line.

Defining an ideal state doesn’t just change mindsets — it transforms the way teams operate day-to-day.

What Framing Success Actually Changes

  • Prevents wasted effort: Teams save energy by moving toward a shared goal, not just away from pain.
  • Drives honest evaluation: Every idea gets tested against the same definition of winning.
  • Builds courage: People risk more when they know what matters most.
  • Rewires the brain for growth: Clear purpose forges new neural pathways for resilience and learning.

Questions:

I was working with a VP at a large insurance company whose division was performing exceptionally well. His numbers were excellent, and his people were being promoted at a higher rate than any other department. In our conversation, he shared what he believed to be the practice that propelled his group to top performance. He said:

“When one of my people calls with a question or approaches me with an issue, I ask myself, ‘Is this a crisis that needs to be solved right away, or is this an opportunity for development?’ If it’s not an emergency with high-stakes consequences I look at it as an opportunity for development and ask something like ‘what would this look like when it’s no longer a problem?’ I encourage them to look past the issue to success.”

This VP practiced a timely pause to quickly assess the opportunities present in this interaction. He embodied the phrase “Don’t just do something. Sit there.” No crisis or emergency isn’t better served by a momentary pause. In the time it takes for a deep breath, you engage your best thinking (prefrontal cortex, executive functions) and begin to see opportunities rather than urgency. He credits the practice of the pause as the key to his division’s success.

With this in mind, here are simple but powerful questions every leader can use to shift from reflexive problem-solving to intentional success framing.

Three Questions to Ask Yourself Before Acting

1. Is this really an urgent problem or request?

2. How could this situation serve to develop this person?

3. What are the actual risks of using this as a development opportunity?

Three Questions to Ask Others Before Acting

  1. What does success look like, painted so clearly that everyone can see it?
  2. Are we solving for fear, or building toward desire?
  3. Is this plan aiming at the target, or are we painting bullseyes around random arrows?

Call to Action

Ultimately, painting your target first is both a discipline and a mindset. The results and the difference show up at every level of leadership.

The next time someone asks, “Just tell me what to do,” resist the urge to hand over a script. Pause. Paint the target together. Clarity isn’t delay; it’s the compass that keeps you from wandering in circles.

Define what great looks like, then aim your next shot. That’s how leaders stop pretending they hit the bullseye, and actually do.

If you’re curious, here are some Brain Science References:

  • Berkman, E. T. (2018). The Neuroscience of Goals and Behavior Change. Consulting Psychology Journal, 70(1):28–44.
  • “Setting Goals That Drive Success in 2025: A Neuroscience Perspective — Rewire for Success.”
  • “Mind the Gap,” Psychology Today (2017 Jan 24).

(All images by Adobe Stock, and John Losey)

(AI was used in this article for research, grammar, and feedback. All content is the work of the author. The author has significantly edited any contributions from AI.)


This article first appeared on Medium.

How IntoWisdom can help

If this is something your organization is working on, IntoWisdom’s work in these areas may be useful:

About the author

John Losey

John Losey is the founder of IntoWisdom Group. For more than 30 years he has helped leaders, teams and organizations navigate challenges, develop people and turn ideas into practical action.

More about John Losey

Tools to put this into practice

More on Leadership

Where to go from here

Keep reading, or start a conversation about what you’re working on.